Pages

Translate

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

The Rosenhan Experiment Meets Reality TV

 With contestants lined up on the lawn of a grand house and looking as if they mean business, the opening sequence of Horizon: How Mad Are You? could be mistaken for The Apprentice. But the 10 "contestants" in the BBC2 programme aren't competing for prizes. They are willingly being scrutinised by psychiatric professionals who have to spot which five have a diagnosed mental illness.

Three professionals observe the group over a number of days, during which they complete tasks designed to expose signs of mental illness. One task involves performing stand-up comedy so the professionals can detect anxiety disorders. It makes for interesting viewing as the professionals struggle to pinpoint those with a condition and are frequently prompted to question their own "clinical intuition". The premise is that viewers are encouraged to question their own notions of mental illness and to recognise the effects of stigma.

At the end of the first episode, misconceptions are challenged when someone the professionals are certain has no history of mental illness reveals they have a psychiatric condition.
The programme is likely to raise many questions about how mental illness is diagnosed. And by reminding the public that even professionals get it wrong, it may offer a boost for people who have been judged because of their condition.

• How Mad Are You? is on BBC2 at 9pm on November 11 and 18. Details at bbc.co.uk/headroom

No comments:

Post a Comment